Understand GurusupHow conflicts work

How conflicts work

How Gurusup notices when your sources disagree, which cases it settles itself, and which ones reach an admin or a member.

This page explains why a conflict appears in Gurusup, why most disagreements never become one, and what happens after someone decides. Admins and members see Conflicts, but a member sees only the conflicts whose source and categories they can read. To settle a case, see Resolve conflicts.

Companies say different things in different places. A Notion page gives one price, a Slack thread gives another. Gurusup notices these disagreements while it learns, settles the clear ones itself, and sends only the real ones to Conflicts.

How Gurusup notices a disagreement

Gurusup checks for disagreement each time it learns new content. When something it has just read does not fit with something already in Brain, for example a different date, price or owner for the same thing, it treats the pair as a possible conflict and looks at both sides.

Gurusup looks at the evidence on each side and decides which of four kinds of situation it is. Three of them it settles on its own. Only the fourth reaches Conflicts.

The three kinds Gurusup settles itself

KindWhat happenedWhat Gurusup does
A later source replaces an earlier oneThe facts changed over time. A newer message gives a new date, or a newer document supersedes an old one.Treats the newer fact as current. The older one stays in the history, marked as replaced.
A source corrects anotherOne source explicitly says another was wrong, for example "the owner corrected the date".Treats the correction as current.
Both are true in different contextsThe two statements apply to different situations, such as different plans, regions or quarters.Keeps both, each tied to its context.

Gurusup does not decide that a fact was replaced only because two documents show different dates. It needs the evidence that one replaces or corrects the other.

The counters at the top of Conflicts, which only admins see, show how much of this happens by itself. Candidate evaluations counts the pairs Gurusup compared. Auto-reconciled counts the ones it settled. Unique cases raised counts the distinct conflicts Gurusup opened. Automation rate is the second number divided by the first.

What makes a conflict real

A conflict is real when the two statements are about the same thing, apply at the same time and in the same context, and no source says which one is right. Neither replaces the other. That is what Gurusup cannot decide, and it is what shows up under Open.

Each case comes with:

  • a subject and the reason Gurusup raised it,
  • an access badge, Organization, Restricted or Private, and the category, which decide who can see the case,
  • the Conflicting alternatives, at least two, each with its text and, when Gurusup has them, its authority and dates,
  • a Decision needed question.

Severity

Gurusup gives each case a severity: low, medium, high or critical. It is shown on the card as, for example, "high severity". The page sorts cases by severity first, then by the most recent update.

The four statuses

TabWhat it means
OpenNeeds a decision. Only cases here have buttons.
Awaiting responseGurusup is checking a decision you made, or a colleague has been asked and has not answered. Cards say Waiting for Gurusup to verify or Waiting for a contact.
ResolvedThe case is closed with a verified decision.
DismissedThe case was closed as not really contradictory.

What a decision does

Admins and members decide with the same options, and Gurusup records who decided. Your decision is not applied straight to Brain. It becomes new evidence: what you chose and, in How do you know?, why. Gurusup then verifies it. If the evidence is enough, the case moves to Resolved, or to Dismissed if you said the sources did not really disagree. Gurusup updates Brain to the understanding the evidence supports and keeps the history of what the sources said.

If the evidence is not enough, the case can go back to Open.

You can decide in four ways:

DecisionUse it when
Confirm an alternativeOne of the alternatives is correct.
Each is true in a different contextBoth hold in different situations. You say where each applies.
Write the correct statementNeither alternative is right.
Dismiss as not contradictoryThe sources do not really disagree.

Reopening

A closed case is not final. If later content makes a resolved or dismissed case genuinely incompatible again, Gurusup reopens it and it comes back under Open. A case that was waiting for a colleague also returns to Open when new evidence changes it.

Asking a colleague

If an admin does not know which alternative is right, they can use Ask a contact on an open case. Members do not get this button. Gurusup reaches a Gurusup contact through Slack or a call, and the contact only sees a safe summary of the alternatives. Until the contact answers, the case sits in Awaiting response as Waiting for a contact.

Who can be asked depends on who you set up as a contact. See Gurusup contacts and external contacts.